Recent Comments

Tip Jar

for NewsCloud

Tip Jar

Stats

NewsCloud.com Front Page

Media Convergence: New York Times and South Park?

In case you missed it, the New York Times Editorial page issued a treatise on Comedy Central's South Park today:

"While some say convergence is the merger between print and the Internet, or video and the Internet or all kinds of stuff on your iPod or the iPhone ... I say convergence is when the standard bearer of print journalism uses its editorial page to praise your favorite black sheep."

Technorati Tags: , ,

Knight News Challenge Winners Announced; MIT Tops List With $5 Million

Editor and Publisher reports the MIT Media Lab received a $5 million grant from the Knight Foundation "to create a Center for Future Civic Media to develop, test, and study new forms of high-tech community news." Other winners included $700k to MTV for mobile youth journalists to cover the 2008 election. ChicagoCrime received $1.1M "to create a series of city-specific Web sites devoted to public records and hyper-local information" and VillageSoup received $885K "to build free software to allow others to replicate the citizen journalism and community participation." E & P also reports "Eleven other grants of between $25,000 and $340,000 were awarded...[and]...nine bloggers will each get $15,000 to blog about topics ranging from GPS tracking devices to 'out-of-the-box' community publishing solutions." Congrats to all the winners!

For the rest of us, there's always next year. Entries start up for 2007 July 1st, but are more narrowly focused than last year:

Anybody, anywhere in the world is eligible for funding — if the project meets all of the following criteria:

1. Use digital media.
2. Involve new forms of news in the public interest.
3. Focus on specific geographic community.

NewsCloud entered its open source platform in 2006. Although we were asked to submit a secondary application, we were not selected as a winner.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Crosscut reports Hearst to Test Market E Paper in Seattle

The Hearst Corporation plans to use the Seattle Post-Intelligencer to test market LG Philipps' recently announced flexible color E-Paper.
The electronic P-I will carry real-time news, same as the Internet, not yesterday's news like traditional papers. Readers will turn the e-paper's pages by touching the flexible screen. And when those readers head off to work, they will roll up the electronic P-I and stuff it in their pocket, purse, or briefcase.
The announcement comes amidst the recent settlement of bitter co-operating disputes between Seattle's two newspapers and Bill Gates' recent comments on the shifting of the advertising market away from traditional media.
"[Seattle] is a great market for trying this out," says Ken Bronfin of Hearst Interactive. The city has a large computer-literate population, a built-in test bed for Hearst in the P-I, and competition from The Seattle Times, which would provide a daily comparison for reader acceptance of an electronic P-I. Hearst bought a piece of E Ink, a Cambridge, Mass.-based company that was spun off from MIT's Media Lab about 10 years ago.
Now if they can make this thing transform into an umbrella...

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Using technology for good or evil

There's been a joke going around the past few years about how the Bush administration read Orwell's 1984 and thought it was a how to guide. Yesterday, a popular journalism blog at the Poynter Institute's Web site linked to my "Billionaire's Guide to Stopping the Theft of Your Online Newspaper Content". The story has been widely read and even TotalFark picked it up. I'm sort of wondering now, will publishers read it as thoughtful criticism on the gap in technical acumen between wealthy billionaire Sam Zell and the online community or as a how to guide for them to restrict access to their sites.

If you find yourself unable to select and copy excerpts or print pages from the LA Times, we'll know the answer.

Technorati Tags: ,

A billionaire's guide to stopping "theft" of your online newspaper content...and relegating your business to obscurity

Recently, I wrote that billionaire Sam Zell's inflammatory remarks about Google stealing the content of online newspapers seemed unfair and inaccurate:

“If all of the newspapers in America did not allow Google to steal their content for nothing, what would Google do?” he asked. “We have a situation today where effectively the content is being paid for by the newspapers and stolen by Google, etcetera. That can last for a short time, but it can’t last forever. I think Google and the boys understand that."
- Sam Zell, Stanford Business Daily

Google isn't stealing this material. The newspapers have left the content wide open - and simply haven't asked Google not to use it. Google News appropriates Fair Use materials (captions and image thumbnails) and subsequently drives significant traffic through to online news sites that might not otherwise receive page views or revenues from these readers (at this time, Google News does not even earn revenue from this activity). A reporter from the Seattle Post-Intelligencer recently said that 10 percent of their sites traffic comes from Google News. Online news aggregators like Google News and NewsCloud are good for the online newspaper business.

Yet, I feel bad for Mr. Zell, having spent $8 billion dollars on the Los Angeles Times and Chicago Tribune and barely having any technical knowledge of how the Internets work. To help him out, I've written an easy how to guide for stopping "theft" of your online newspaper content ... but it might as well be called "How to relegate your online newspaper to obscurity and minimize your subscriber base" or "Minimizing the bandwidth usage of your online newspapers" or "My Secrets of Search engine de-optimization". Mr. Zell needs to understand that the way these sites are operating today is essentially like leaving your garage door open every day with a sign that says "Community Tool Lending Library". You're just asking for someone to use your stuff.

Here are my eight easy steps to stop the Google Boys from driving traffic to your business:

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Continue reading "A billionaire's guide to stopping "theft" of your online newspaper content...and relegating your business to obscurity" »

Knight Foundation's Results to Be Announced May 23, 2007

Here's an update on the Knight Foundation Challenge:

The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation will announce the first-year winners of the Knight News Challenge on May 23 at the Interactive Media Conference & Tradeshow in Miami, hosted by Editor & Publisher and Mediaweek.

The Knight News Challenge – a contest open to anyone, anywhere – offers $25 million over five years in awards for news experiments that use digital media to build communities in specific geographic areas. The first year’s winners range from individuals to corporations and were chosen from among 1,650 applicants after recommendations by a panel of experts in digital media. They will receive a total of $12 million, including several multi-year awards. Applications for the 2007 round can be submitted at www.newschallenge.org starting July 1.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Traffic statistics for Yahoo and Google News vs. other news sites

Yahoo and Google News are truly behemoths in news aggregation on the Web. All these statistics are based on Alexa data (so accuracy may vary) but Google News has 5 to 10 times the reach of MSNBC, the Guardian UK, the New York Times and Digg (Yahoo News is similar). Click to enlarge the images.

Googlenews Reach-1

If you take Google News out, you can see that Digg has greater reach with Alexa users than other news Web sites including the New York Times.

Generalnews Reach-1

In the technology space, Digg and News.com are more widely read by Alexa users than Slashdot, Engadget or TechCrunch:

Techreach-1

Now you can read Paul's take on why you should ignore Alexa stats:

Josh Pigford, the creator of The Apple Blog, has posted an extremely well-written rant of sorts regarding the major flaw with Alexa website traffic statistics. Alexa is a serviced owned by Amazon that provides website traffic statistics based on information collected from web surfers with the Alexa toolbar installed. The problem is that the Alexa toolbar only runs on Internet Explorer on Windows machines, effectively voiding every single alternative browser and Mac user.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

The three things I don't like about Newsvine

Newsvine is another local Seattle social news startup. They have six employees and about $1.25 million in funding. They are different than NewsCloud in that they focus a lot on original material whereas NewsCloud is more of an aggregator using citizens as editors.

The three things I don't like about Newsvine are:

1) The big green monster at the top of every page. I find it big, dark and confusing...

Nvhead

2) As they license the Associated Press feed, they seed much of their site with only AP content. Readers can submit from other sources but I find the primary content very mainstream. Check out the NewsCloud Newswire for a more diversified approach.

3) They lock readers into their blogging service. Newsvine authors are essentially bloggers who only blog about newsy material and only on Newsvine. With such great blog tools such as WordPress (free), Blogger (free) and TypePad out there, why lock their members into a proprietary tool. Blogging is meant to be more than just news. I just find the idea of Newsvine's proprietary blogging service very restrictive. Btw, NewsCloud's approach is to allow readers to blog stories to almost any third party service - our approach is open.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Defending Google News' Right to Aggregate vs. Sam Zell

As NewsCloud is an aggregator like Google News, I acknowledge clear bias. That said, Sam Zell's recent comments about Google News don't make sense to me:

“If all of the newspapers in America did not allow Google to steal their content for nothing, what would Google do?” he asked. “We have a situation today where effectively the content is being paid for by the newspapers and stolen by Google, etcetera. That can last for a short time, but it can’t last forever. I think Google and the boys understand that. We’re going to see new deals and new formulas in the media space that reflect the reality of cost benefit.” Source The Stanford Daily.

I don't see a single advertisement on Google News. All I see is a site that has become popular, driving tons of traffic to newspaper Web sites around the world. The traffic that Google generates for these Web sites is captured as revenue by and for the publishers, not Google. I recently heard a Seattle Post-Intelligencer reporter say that 10% of their site traffic is due to Google News and that they routinely get traffic from around the world that they would not have otherwise. Google News represents a business opportunity. Perhaps not seeing this is why the newspapers are failing.

If newspapers don't want to share their headlines and abstracts, stop publishing RSS feeds. Furthermore, if you don't want Google News to crawl your content, exclude them in your robots.txt file (for you non-technologists, there is a simple way for newspapers to set up their Web sites to be excluded from Google News).

Is Zell out to outlaw the hyperlink?

There is a gigantic difference between the fair use involved in republishing headlines and abstracts (offered in an automated format to everyone via the newspaper's RSS feeds as well as left open in robots.txt) vs. the full length video clips of Daily Show segments republished by YouTube. These scenarios are apples and oranges. It's unfair to compare them.

"If all of the newspapers in America did not allow Google to steal their content, how profitable would Google be?" Zell said during the question period after his speech. "Not very."

Is Sam Zell really this clueless (he did just pay $8.2 billion for an allegedly declining newspaper empire)? Has he not noticed that Google search significant revenue-based business models well beyond news?

Technorati Tags: , , ,

NewsTrust: High quality stories from a few days ago

I've been following the NewsTrust feed with great interest. I think their ranking system is a fantastic idea. However, it does seem to be suffering from a lack of adequate community of people to rate stories as they break. Timeliness is an extremely important quality in news - as much as quality and accuracy. The stories that come across my NewsTrust feed are three or more days old in most cases. They are interesting, vetted, well-written but old.

It could be that they don't have a large enough pool of people rating stories. It could be that the complexity of their rating system turns off new raters.

I also heard through the grapevine that they use a content management system that is very difficult to extend and will probably have to switch platforms before they can significantly improve the Web site. This is mostly speculative but I heard it from a good source.

Kudos to NT for a great concept and decent initial execution, but it's time to speed up that ratings queue!

Technorati Tags:

Knight Foundation Announces Another News Challenge, No Results Yet

The Knight Foundation has announced another news challenge for 2007, clarifying their focus a bit further:

In 2007, Knight Foundation will again award $5 million in grants to individuals, organizations or businesses with ideas and projects that will transform community news. Anybody, anywhere in the world is eligible for funding — if the project meets all of the following criteria:

1. Use digital media.
2. Involve new forms of news in the public interest.
3. Focus on specific geographic community.

This site will begin accepting applications on July 1, 2007. Please do not try to send in applications before.

I think it's fair to ask, where are the results from the last News Challenge? Personally, I'd like to see the results from last years before applying again.

Technorati Tags: ,

Crosscut to launch April 2nd

Crosscut, a news aggregator for the Pacific Northwest region, launches April 2nd. It's technology is partly inspired by NewsCloud.

Disclaimer, the founder of NewsCloud is a minority investor in Crosscut.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Frontiers of Innovation in Community Engagement

Craig Newmark helped fund a new report by the Center for Citizen Media. It's called Frontiers of Innovation in Community Engagement:

In this report, we look at the first generation of traditional-media innovators in community engagement online. We’ll be talking about what worked, and what didn’t, in this early round of experimentation. If you’re interested in the movement towards “crowdsourcing,” “citizen journalism,” or “user generated content” by traditional media organizations such as newspapers and television news programs, you'll find information about some of the major efforts underway today.

You can download a printable version of the full report (PDF, 3.2 MB).

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Knight Foundation News Challenge Results

So, the Knight Foundation News Challenge results are trickling in ... and although NewsCloud made the finals, we did not receive an award. In the spirit of our open source platform, I'm considering posting a PDF of our application in case people want to look at what we proposed. We had applied in the Leadership category which is specifically for scaling up ideas and prototypes.

NewsCloud is one of the only open source social networks for news so it will be interesting what the Knight folks chose instead. It's possible they thought NewsCloud was overly me-too like Digg and others. However, Digg is not an open source platform that can be used to launch new grassroots media sites. It's also possible that the impact on real world communities was not clear in our proposal. I think that's part of the risk in applying for an idea that must be scaled to have more impact. Still another possibility is that they chose to fund an organization like Drupal or Wikia, two organizations that are working to extend their platforms to support social news sites...both are well-funded safe bets with a track record...the kind of sites that more traditional foundations like to fund. The Knight challenge though seemed to want to fund edgy new stuff. We'll see...

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Assignment Zero takes on Crowdsourced Journalism

Slashdot links to a Wired article on Assignment Zero, NewAssignment's effort at crowdsourced journalism. Crowdsourced journalism attempts to apply large numbers of highly motivated Internet users to perform the tasks of professional, paid journalists. It's a great concept - difficult to make happen in practice at scale at this point. Still, I expect to see at least a few great pieces from this project every few months.

NewsCloud takes a crowdsourced approach to editorial. Editorial tasks tend to be lighter weight and more accessible to large numbers of Internet news readers. Editorial tasks traditionally are most influenced by education, background and corporate influence - so diversifying the people performing these tasks can have a huge impact on the openness of a media publication.

I expect that these models will be synergistic and work well together. I hope to see some Assignment Zero stories on NewsCloud soon.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Justin Cole of Media Matters is This Week's Spotlight Blogger

Justin is the Online Outreach Coordinator of Media Matters for America. His first post this week is about Ann Coulter calling John Edwards a faggot and how the media is covering or not covering it. Read the story and join the conversation.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Important of Citizen Journalism: A picture worth a thousand words

I'm not making this stuff up:
Msnbc An

Technorati Tags: ,

Knight Citizen News Network

Received a link today of a new resource funded by the Knight Foundation:

Knight Citizen News Network

ABOUT KCNN The Knight Citizen News Network is a self-help portal that guides both ordinary citizens and traditional journalists in launching and responsibly operating community news and information sites and that assembles news innovations and research on citizen media projects.

Looks like an interesting start of a helpful resource for sites like NewsCloud and other citizen media efforts.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Glossary of online journalism terms

From USC's Online Journalism review:

Glossary of online journalism terms

Thanks Chuck!

Technorati Tags: , ,

When the mainstream media gets it wrong...and doesn't correct itself

Since posting at NewsCloud, I've broken two stories:

1) In October 2006, I reported that YouTube began a purge of Comedy Central clips, sending out copyright notices to users and taking down Daily Show, Colbert Report and South Park clips.

2) In January 2007, I reported that the Gates Foundation revoked its pledge to review the social responsibility of its investment practices.

I've been fascinated in each case at how the mainstream media inadvertently propagates false or outdated information and often never corrects itself. Online media and search engines are often equally wrong, but sometimes serve to publish corrections that the mainstream sites don't.

After the Los Angeles Times published Dark Cloud Over Good Works of Gates Foundation, the foundation told the Seattle Times that Bill and Melinda would personally oversee a comprehensive review of its investments. This report was repeated over and over again, here are just a few examples:

Gates Foundation to Review Investments (Seattle Times)
Gates Foundation to Reassess Investments (Los Angeles Times)
Gates Foundation may shift billions into ethical stocks after attack on investments (Guardian UK)
Gates Foundation Reviews Investments (Chronical of Philanthropy)
Gates Foundation to Review Investments (UPI)
Gates Foundation Reviewing Investments (AP)
Gates Foundation launches investment review (The Register UK)
Review in train as social conscience pricks Gates (The Age AU)
Gates Foundation to review investments after criticism (The New Standard)

Then, after NewsCloud reported that the Gates Foundation revoked this pledge (also linked by Slashdot), only a few updated articles were posted, few if any corrections. I don't think UPI ever published a correction to the wires, though AP did. Most of the coverage of the revocation occurred in different sources:

Gates Foundation faces multibillion-dollar dilemma (Seattle Times)
Gates Foundation to keep its investment approach (Los Angeles Times)
Gates in snub to ethical investment movement (Financial Times)
Gates Foundation not changing investment practices (AP)
Whiplash at the Gates Foundation (Huffington Post)

With Google, you can now track the evolution of these kinds of reports, just search on Gates Foundation, click News, then sort by date. You can see the thread as it evolves over time. But Google is no truth-meter. Google on Gates Foundation today and you will still get the impression that the Gateses will review their investments. This story appears on the first page of results but no mention of the updated story appears until you click for following pages.

In Anatomy of a Fast One, Geov Parrish discusses the benefits of this to the Gates Foundation, the weakness in commentary of the Seattle Times and the loss to the public:

What we have, then, is a massive investment firm (embedded in a multi-billion dollar philanthropy) smoothly reassuring the public while changing its odious practices not a whit; and the hometown paper first publicizing the odious practices and then, obediently, helping make it all right and sunshiney again.

The only losers are the millions of people around the globe victimized by the practices of firms invested in by the Gates Foundation; and local news consumers who think that the Seattle Times, for once, cast an unfettered, critical eye on a feelgood local institution. In both cases, it’s bad news.

Kudos to Seattlest for laying out the facts and crediting us as a source for the follow up story.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

Continue reading "When the mainstream media gets it wrong...and doesn't correct itself" »

How to file a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Request

How to use the Federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) seems to layout the basic of the Freedom of Information Act and explains how to make requests and appeals. A Citizen's Guide On Using The Freedom Of Information Act And The Privacy Act of 1974 To Request Government Records is pretty similar.

Technorati Tags: ,

This is what citizen journalism looks like

In Gates Foundation Not Reviewing Investments After All, Seattlest was kind enough to acknowledge that Idealog, the blog of NewsCloud's founder, broke this story early (both to Idealog and NewsCloud):

Last Wednesday the Seattle Times reported the story of the Foundation's pledge to review their investments. However, that fantasy world was quickly revealed to be a sham. The Idealog blog smelled the Foundation's backtrack way before it was reported in the in an editorial in the L.A. Times over the weekend in which the Gates Foundation CEO basically says, "Screw you, we aren't changing shit. C'mon, little people, do you really think we don't know what we're doing here? $66 billion isn't some boutique fund that can afford to care about anything other than sustaining itself. Sure, we're in it for 'doing good' with our gigantic pile of money - The problem is that there is no greater good than a gigantic pile of money."

Well said Dan.

Geov Parrish also gave us credit at HorsesAss today (Geov is an advisor at NewsCloud):

And, it turns out, there was another problem: talk is cheap, and, it quietly emerged, fully retractable. Two days after that, on Friday, the web site NewsCloud.com broke a story bluntly headlined “Gates Foundation Revokes Pledge to Review Portfolio.” Our beneficent local philanthropists got their message out, and then changed it.


It's great seeing other blogs highlight the citizen journalists breaking news (and great when it's us).

Mainstream media outlets are reticent to source blogs, but I think this is slowly changing.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Wikileaks - an anoymous site for posting leaked documents

Wikileaks could turn out to be interesting for citizen journalists. Let's keep our eye on it.

Technorati Tags: ,

Daylife opens beta site - heavy traffic slows site

Daylife opened for business today and seems to have been greatly slowed by traffic, but reviews haven't been kind either. The article links to a site that claims that Daylife has more investors than employees. That's not entirely unusual in a startup - but still makes me glad we've kept NewsCloud small so far.

Technorati Tags:

WorldChanging's Jon Lebkowsky on NewsCloud and NewsTrust

From Weblogsky:

Thanks to Boing Boing for posting a pointer to a comparison of Digg and NewsTrust at Mercury News. I'm not a Digg fan, but NewsTrust is intriguing. – stories are rated on ten factors. Will I read it? Not sure. Newscloud is similar and even more interesting than NewsTrust, I think. It's a news-sharing community.

I think the NewsTrust folks have done some great initial work and I look forward to seeing how the service evolves.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Microsoft's Approach to Citizen Journalists: Buy them

Apparently, Microsoft's attitude toward citizen journalists is that they can be easily bought, perhaps for less than the mainstream media. The company gave out free laptops to a number of bloggers.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Using journalism to save lives

A rash of carbon monoxide poisonings in the wake of Seattle's recent windstorm led the Seattle Times to publish a multi-lingual warning (PDF) about using indoor heating elements on the top of their front page. This is a great example of journalists using their unique place in our cities to save lives. Kudos to the Seattle Times and kudos to the LA Times for noticing.

Now if we could just get them to endorse candidates with the same sort of ethical considerations rather than routinely endorsing Republicans to push for an estate tax ban in one of America's most liberal cities.

Technorati Tags: , ,

One Laptop Per Child News Mentions NewsCloud

The One Laptop Per Child folks wrote about our slashdot post on Eben Moglen from the other day:

Skipping over the OLPC implementation plan realities for a moment, imagine a world where many students have a Children's Machine XO. A world described by Eben Moglen in his Plone Conference Keynote Address and transcribed by The NewsCloud Blog...

As part of the OLPC-enabled content overload, there would be an amazing opportunity to reshape the public discourse with an unprecedented level of inclusion.

Opportunity because One Laptop Per Child cannot guarantee such openness. As China proves with its successful censorship, yet denial of that very censorship, open technology does not equate to actual openness of expression.

Still, a solid OLPC cultural integration plan could go a long way to enabling such citizen journalism revolution. The ultimate crowd sourced CNN.

Read more

Technorati Tags: , ,

New York Times partners with Digg, Facebook and Newsvine

John Cook reports that the New York Times has added a sharing feature for readers to post their content to Digg, Facebook and Newsvine as well as a long overdue permalink for their stories.

The sharing feature will not be used on TimesSelect stories, the newspaper's premium content offering, nor will it be available on staff blogs or wire stories

Christine Topalian, manager of strategic planning and business development at NYTimes.com, said it was looking for ways to tap a tech-savvy audience that is accustomed to commenting on and sharing news stories. ... The Times would not rule out adding comments to stories directly on NYTimes.com. Other partners may be added, though Topalian said the company was happy to start with Digg, Newsvine and Facebook.

I think it's great to see the New York times experiment with a distributed network impact rather than building comments directly on their site, though I expect they will eventually do that too.

I agree with GigaOm that:

"Discussions or not, it is about capturing them page views, and it is not a bad move, though I question how much traffic Facebook and Newsvine can drive to the Times."

I think the Times sees this as a dipping their toe into a space they don't presently have technology to address. This is a way to experiment and innovate without taking much risk at all. Still, it seems like a gift-horse for the Newsvine folks - exposure to a very large established audience and the credibility of the paper of record.

Cook reports:

"Davidson declined to comment when asked if The New York Times had considered investing in Newsvine. He said there is no revenue-sharing agreement, adding that it is simply a technology deal."

Editor & Publisher had some additional Times quotes:

"We"re very excited about offering our readers a new tool to share their favorite New York Times content," said Vivian Schiller, NYTimes.com senior vice president and general manager, in a statement. "This new capability extends the Web-based conversation while encouraging new communities of readers to share and discuss a wide range of interests, whether by linking to an article about politics from their homepage or adding coverage of world news to their blogs."

It's not clear what this move means for smaller, independent and open source efforts like NewsCloud. Clearly, it doesn't make our job easier - but I'm not sure the long term impact will be that big. The New York Times is leaving the door open to other partners... let's just hope they don't end up looking like this:

ridiculous bookmarks

If the New York Times decides they really want to extend discussion of their content to bloggers, they should support blogging APIs such as Flickr has done. This allows any New York Times reader to post directly to their blog from the New York Times Web site.

Additionally, they could create a generic API for third party services to hook into that allows New York Times readers to select the bookmarking services that they want to use e.g. del.icio.us, et al.

An interesting footnote in the Cook article was that it said Newsvine "has raised about $1 million in venture financing" last year, whereas Cook previously reported Newsvine was "Backed with less than $5 million from Second Avenue Partners". I always wondered what "less than $5 million" meant, now we know.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Eben Moglen on The One Laptop Per Child and Citizen Journalism

Nigerian-Machine As I mention here, I finally watched Eben Moglen's keynote from the 2006 Plone Conference that my friend Jon has been raving about for weeks. Moglen made some great comments on the potential of the One Laptop Per Child project to affect citizen journalism:

"What is journalism like when every village has a video camera and is on the net? ...

What does it mean if the next time somebody starts some nasty little genocide in some little corner of the Earth the United States government would prefer to ignore, that there's video all over the place all the time in every living room?

What does it mean when children around the world are networking with one another over the issues that concern them directly without intermediation, everybody to everybody?"

Every OLPC is specified with a video camera. Here's a recent New York Times article on the One Laptop Per Child project.

It made me happy that I released most of my work from the past two years to the open source community this week.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Help pick the most important issues to cover in 2007

What are the most important beats for us to cover in 2007? Only you can tell us.

Visit our Hot Topics of 2007 page to vote on what you think will be the most important area for citizen editorial attention next year. If you don't see an important issue, suggest one.

More importantly, we're taking volunteer sign ups from readers and bloggers who want to help select stories within these topic areas next year. Want to be the go-to citizen editor for "habeas corpus"? Now you can...

We'll wrap up the voting at midnight on December 31 and announce the top focus areas in January.

As always, send any feedback you have to me via email.

2007-1

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Our thoughts on Framing News Stories

Recently, we received an email from a NewsCloud reader about the way we use iFrames to show news stories:

I feel kind of strongly that linking to content is great but that's what it should be -- a link and not a display within artificial context. For one thing, does the Post or any other site get a page view every time their article is viewed on NewsCloud? If not, this deprives them of revenue that pays for their journalism, the journalism that sites like NewsCloud depend on without having to compensate the creators.

NewsCloud does use iFrames to display stories, for example - here. Because the iFrame fully loads the entire page of the news site, they receive a standard page view and all their normal advertising page views. The iFrame technology is no different than opening Firefox and pointing our address bar at the URL for the story (the iFrame loads the source page as if it was loaded by a browser). NewsCloud is essentially a more specialized browser in this situation i.e. a news-browser.

However, if a site doesn't want us to frame their stories, they can email us and we'll turn off the feature for their site. Some sites, like the New York Times, use Javascript code like this to break out of framed pages. So, we just link to their sites.

You tell me which story is more likely to generate a page view for the original site, this one (doesn't allow frames) or this one (allows frames).

Technorati Tags: , , ,

EFF Web Site for Bloggers (and citizen journalists)

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has a Web site for bloggers which includes a legal guide:

Bloggers can be journalists (and journalists can be bloggers) - We're battling for legal and institutional recognition that if you engage in journalism, you're a journalist, with all of the attendant rights, privileges, and protections. (See Apple v. Does.)

Bloggers are entitled to free speech - We're working to shield you from frivolous or abusive threats and lawsuits. Internet bullies shouldn't use copyright, libel, or other claims to chill your legitimate speech. (See OPG v. Diebold.)

Bloggers have the right to political speech - We're working with a number of other public-interest organizations to ensure that the Federal Election Commission (FEC) doesn't gag bloggers' election-related speech. We argue that the FEC should adopt a presumption against the regulation of election-related speech by individuals on the Internet, and interpret the existing media exemption to apply to online media outlets that provide news reporting and commentary regarding an election -- including blogs. (See our joint comments to the FEC; [PDF, 332K].)

Bloggers have the right to stay anonymous - We're continuing our battle to protect and preserve your constitutional right to anonymous speech online, including providing a guide to help you with strategies for keeping your identity private when you blog. (See How to Blog Safely (About Work or Anything Else).)

Bloggers have freedom from liability for hosting speech the same way other web hosts do - We're working to strengthen Section 230 liability protections under the Communications Decency Act (CDA) while spreading the word that bloggers are entitled to them. (See Barrett v. Rosenthal.)

Technorati Tags: , , ,

The Most Useful Web Sites For Reporters

This page is somewhat interesting, it's a catalog of industry and governmental information sites for journalists. The Most Useful Web Sites For Reporters

Technorati Tags:

Jon Stewart Mocks CNN's iReport on The Daily Show

Update: here is the new working link to Daily Show's CNN iReport Clip on iFilm. It's long since been taken down off of YouTube.

Jon Stewart mocked CNN's iReport on the Daily Show - making fun of CNN's rabid pursuit of shallow citizen journalism. The best line: "This just in, my balls are on Wolf Blitzer's head!" Enjoy!

Technorati Tags: , , , , , ,